|
|
 |
 |
|
|

|
Maggots
To The Rescue!
Review:
Blade of the Immortal
Updated: 10/14/03
Manga/Fandom
Title
rating: R for violence, gore, language, and adult situations.
Keep away from children!
-Original
manga
published in the Japanese magazine "Afternoon"
(1997-present), still running
-11+
graphic novels in English, translated
by Studio
Proteus and published by Dark
Horse Comics (2000-present),
still running
|
|
I made a mistake
with this series. You see, a friend of mine wanted me to
read it and promptly gave me the sixth book to sample first.
After a quick trip to the closest bookstore (which did not
have the first two books, to my anguish), I read the third
book second. As a result, this is the order I have read
this series in: 6, 3-5, 9, 8, etc. So you might say that
my experience with Blade of the Immortal is somewhat scrambled.
Confusing? Oh yes. But I was still able to enjoy this excellent
manga
series, which should be a testament of its quality...and
it is, if you're willing to hear out why.
And by the way,
Blade of the Immortal won Japan's 1998 Media Art Award and
the Will Eisner Comics Industry Award. Don't just take my
word for it.
Manga
bishounen
|
All the major
characters (i.e. the ones that survive at least one story
arc) are three-dimensional and very human. They all have
their own pasts and even (more or less) valid reasons
for committing whatever acts of blasphemy they take their
swords and/or axes to. Even the supposed villains have
hearts deep down and aren't necessarily evil. I found this a unique and intriguing aspect of
the manga, because if you think about it, nobody's really
the villain in Blade--everyone's just trying to get through
life in one piece. Then again, there are also plenty of
violent, evil side-character psychos floating around,
but they pretty much serve as outlets for whatever violent
energy Manji has at the moment.
One of the
prime aspects of Blade that will catch the eye is the
art. The color pictures are dark and dramatic and the
pencil work is beautiful. Samura-sensei has a distinct
style that includes plenty of attention to detail. The
character designs generally do not have the usual big-eyed
manga look; rather, the characters are more realistic
and have their own distinctive traits. As this is a samurai
manga, there are of course fighting scenes all over the
place and blood galore. Although very gory, the fighting
scenes are extremely well-drawn and somehow Samura-sensei
still has time to draw in the equally-detailed backgrounds.
|

I
didn't do it; don't you point that sword at me, young man!
|
The English
adaptation of Blade is extremely well
done. Kowtow to the people at Studio
Proteus for their great translation! The script has
a variety of speaking styles from formal to street punk
and the English translations convey this very nicely.
The translators also leave some of the Japanese terms
in for authenticity and educational value, and there's
a handy glossary for those terms as well.
I think the
only thing that will make people wince with Blade is the
violence. The kesson-chu inside Manji not only heal whatever
injury he has, they can also reattach any cut-off body
part. Convenient isn't it? As a result, the reader gets
accustomed to a hand flying off somewhere in the distance
often followed by a foot; Manji can reattach his limbs,
so no worries. Of course, Manji isn't the only one to
lose a limb or two. It's amazing how bloodily some random
underling can be chopped up. There are also very adult
situations with prostitutes and the like, so don't let
your little brother or sister read this yet. There are
many moments where I think, "He's not really
going to … oh … lovely."
Fandom
Well, there are a decent number of
Blade English fan-sites, but the hype is stronger than the
htmling fandom. This site
has intensive information on everything from characters
to manga covers, and this site
has good general information, longer chapter translations,
a huge image gallery, and lots of links worth checking out
(it also happens to be the site the images on this review
are from). I also found this
and this,
two tattoos of Rin that I find very amusing if a bit obsessive.
On ff.net there is a small
amount of fanfiction that could be worth checking out, and
here
is a Magatsu shrine for those of us obsessed with that funky-haired
tough guy. Not a bad fandom at all, if a little small.
|
|
Overview
It's
hard to argue Blade of the Immortal's quality. Great art,
great story, great characters--it's got everything the
perfect manga has. Still, I think some of the violence
is unnecessarily brutal up to the point where you may
find "Did he really have
to be sliced in half?" applying every dozen pages.
If you're old enough for this title, it shouldn't detract
too much from everything else, so I still give Blade of
the Immortal 4.8 stars out of 5. Feel free
to argue with me about the rating, since I'm up
for a duel...er, debate. And watch the effects this manga
can have on you. 
Dawn-sama
is one of our most organized contributors and blissfully
does things without being asked. She's currently on a
soft chair being displayed to staff as an example of how
to take initiative, and gold pins with her name have already
been handed out.
|

Artistic statement, or samurai porn?...
Artistic
statement, perv.
|
|
Lianne:
This manga is like Rurouni Kenshin for adults (with a bit
less idealism and fewer doe eyes), and I still consider
the English adaptation to be the best in the North American
market. I can find no faults other than the sometimes-excessive
violence and one can really argue that's realistic, so it
gets a perfect 5 stars.
|
|
Text copyright ©
Dawn-sama, October 2003. Pictures are copyright © their
respective owners and are used without permission for this
nonprofit review.
|
|
 |
|